Digital Money: The greatest invention or the biggest scam?

Digital Money: The greatest invention or the biggest scam?

As I explored the online marketplace, my mind delved into the intricate systems that facilitate the revenue generation of banks. This interest extended to the underlying procedures of digital financial transactions, whether executed through credit cards, debit cards, or conventional banking methods. Do we genuinely grasp the intricacies of these systems? Have we ever taken a moment to ponder how banks not only endure but also prosper financially? Have you ever questioned the destination of the $20 you used your Visa Credit Card to spend at the gas station last week?

A Historical Lens on Banking

To gain a broader perspective, let's delve into the rich history of banking. The Banca Monte dei Paschi di Siena, established in 1472 in Siena, Italy, holds the distinction of being the world's oldest continuously operating bank. Initially established as a mount of piety, a charitable institution providing interest-free loans to those in need, it eventually transitioned into a commercial bank offering a wide array of financial services. This transformation marked a pivotal moment in banking history, as the emergence of Banca Monte dei Paschi di Siena spurred the expansion of banking systems across Europe and beyond.

Evolution of the Banking Landscape

Over the course of centuries, the landscape of banking has undergone continuous transformation. The Industrial Revolution introduced innovative financial instruments such as stocks and bonds, empowering banks to raise capital for large-scale projects. The forces of globalization further fueled the growth of international banking.

The 20th century witnessed a radical shift in the banking sector with the advent of new technologies. Electronic banking revolutionized access to financial services, while the internet paved the way for online and mobile banking. Today, the global banking system stands as a complex and intricate network, playing a central role in the world economy by providing diverse financial services to individuals, businesses, and governments.

In the modern era, banks wield immense influence, governing not only financial matters but also impacting the functioning of governments and larger institutions. The financial industry has become the cornerstone of the 21st century. Yet, one cannot help but ponder: How did banks undergo such a remarkable transformation, and how does digital money, particularly in the form of digital currency, contribute to their success?

Exploring the Downsides of Digital Money

Have you ever considered the differences between using physical currency and engaging in card or online transactions? Each method has its own set of advantages and disadvantages, and the same holds true for digital currencies, whether in the form of cards, NFTs, or cryptocurrencies.

Let's examine some of the drawbacks associated with digital money, exploring both the conveniences and concerns surrounding its use.

From Cybersecurity to Government Control

In today's world, the ease of traveling with just a credit/debit card has become a hallmark of the 21st century. The convenience of not carrying physical cash and the simplicity of making purchases with a press of a button through methods like Apple Pay showcase the seamless integration of technology into our daily lives. However, it's crucial to consider the potential downsides.

Health Hazards and Cyber Threats: The Dark Side of Digital Money

One notable concern is the risk of disease transmission through physical money, a primary medium that exchanges hands frequently. In a scenario where cash is the predominant mode of payment, particularly in developing countries, an individual carrying a contagious disease may contaminate banknotes or coins during a transaction. This risk is exemplified by the recent COVID-19 pandemic, emphasizing the potential health hazards associated with physical currency.

Moving on to the cons of digital money, one significant drawback is its susceptibility to cyberattacks. Hackers can target digital wallets, online exchanges, and other digital infrastructure to steal or manipulate funds. The 2016 hack of the cryptocurrency exchange Bitfinex, resulting in the loss of over 119,000 bitcoins, illustrates the vulnerabilities of digital currencies to such attacks.

Another concern lies in the lack of market regulation for digital money. The relatively new and unregulated nature of digital currency leaves users with less oversight, exposing them to potential fraud or unfair practices. Instances like the 2017 PlexCoin ICO scam, which raised over $15 million from investors before being exposed as fraudulent, underscore the risks associated with insufficient market regulation.

Additionally, the irreversible nature of digital currency transactions poses a challenge. Once completed, these transactions offer no recourse in case of mistakes or funds sent to the wrong recipient. This lack of reversibility was demonstrated in a 2013 incident where a Bitcoin user accidentally sent 25 bitcoins (worth approximately $22,000 at the time) to the wrong address with no means of recovery.

Acceptance Challenges and Government Oversight: The Roadblocks of Digital Currency

The limited acceptance of digital currency compared to traditional forms, such as cash or credit cards, adds another layer of inconvenience. Many brick-and-mortar stores do not yet accept digital currency, making it less versatile for everyday purchases.

Furthermore, concerns about government control over digital currency raise questions about privacy and financial freedom. China's 2021 ban on all cryptocurrency transactions and mining activities, citing financial stability and national security concerns, serves as an example of the potential for government intervention in digital currency.

Financial Dynamics and The Journey of Physical and Digital Currency: Tracing the $20 Journey

Let's now explore the financial dynamics of a simple debit/credit transaction in a small store. When making a $20 purchase, banks typically charge a transaction fee of approximately 2-3%, along with a processing fee ranging from $0.30 to $0.50. Assuming a transaction fee of 2.5% and a processing fee of $0.30, the net amount received by the merchant is $19.2 after deducting these fees. This process highlights how banks generate revenue through digital transactions, unlike physical currency transactions that do not involve such deductions.

Notably, the journey of a physical $20 bill in transactions differs significantly from its digital counterpart. Unlike digital transactions with associated fees, a physical $20 bill retains its full value when passed between individuals. The recipient receives the entire $20 without any transaction or processing fees. This distinction emphasizes the unique financial dynamics of physical currency transactions.

Perspective and Contemplation: Navigating Change in Modern Finance

It's important to acknowledge that these thoughts are my personal and open to disagreement. The shift towards digital currency by financial institutions reflects the evolving nature of the world, where change is inevitable and often accompanied by trade-offs. This perspective is shared as a reflection of my personal feelings and observations in the dynamic landscape of modern finance. Hope you enjoyed reading this.

Resources:

7 Oldest Banks in The World - [Oldest.org](file:///C:/Users/nirau/AppData/Local/Temp/msohtmlclip1/01/clip_filelist.xml)

List of oldest banks in continuous operation - Wikipedia

Is cash still king? Examining physical money in a digital world | TechSpot

Ideas: The pros and cons of digital currency - North East Times (netimesmagazine.co.uk)

The digital currencies that matter (economist.com)

A New Era of Digital Money - IMF F&D

Did you find this article valuable?

Support Shashwot Niraula by becoming a sponsor. Any amount is appreciated!